Sunday, September 17, 2006
Email to Mr Beattie
Mr Premier.
Congratulations on your win at the ballot box on saturday, now that you are back at work as stated on several news programs, I would like to know what is happening with the "Goat Track" that is called the Ipswich Motorway.
Before you blame the Federal Govt for all the problems, you might like to read an email that I received from Mr Cameron Thompson the Federal member for Blair.
I would appreciate your comments in response to the email and a progress report as to what is happening to the upgrade of the Ipswich Motorway.
And who is the person who is responsible for controlling any future progress as NOTHING has happened as YET!
You might also like to check out this blog site http://fix-ipswich-motorway-now.blogspot.com
Awaiting your reply.
Maarten
Congratulations on your win at the ballot box on saturday, now that you are back at work as stated on several news programs, I would like to know what is happening with the "Goat Track" that is called the Ipswich Motorway.
Before you blame the Federal Govt for all the problems, you might like to read an email that I received from Mr Cameron Thompson the Federal member for Blair.
I would appreciate your comments in response to the email and a progress report as to what is happening to the upgrade of the Ipswich Motorway.
And who is the person who is responsible for controlling any future progress as NOTHING has happened as YET!
You might also like to check out this blog site http://fix-ipswich-motorway-now.blogspot.com
Awaiting your reply.
Maarten
Reply from Mr Beattie Office.
The Premier
13-Sep (5 days ago)
Thank you for your message to the Premier. Your message has been forwarded to his office.
Ministerials Officer
Office of the Premier
13-Sep (5 days ago)
Thank you for your message to the Premier. Your message has been forwarded to his office.
Ministerials Officer
Office of the Premier
Sunday, September 03, 2006

Recently I received an email from the Federal Member for Blair, email set out what has happened over the last few years in relation to the ongoing saga that is called the Ipswich Motorway. (Goat Track)
Mr Cameron Thompson MP email is interesting reading and all ipswich residents should be concerned.
All I suggest that you let your local Federal and State Politicans know that you personally are FEDUP and want action now!
Mr Thompson email can be viewed at:
http://iparkontheipswichmotorway.blogspot.com/
Also I have taken the step of having a Sign Posted on the Back of my Van to promote the campaign.
Posted by Picasa
Saturday, September 02, 2006
Email from Mr Cameron Thompson MP ( Federal Blair.)
Dear Maarten
Thank you for your email about the Ipswich Motorway. What follows is a blow-by blow response that covers all the history of the motorway since the first Auslink funding was allocated by the Commonwealth in 2004. Since then, I have included regular updates on Ipswich Motorway funding and progress in my electorate newsletter the Thompson Tribune.
Firstly, the funding/building relationship in relation to national highways (those that carry a preponderance of interstate freight): Basically, the Commonwealth is supposed to pay the money, while the State is supposed to provide all the practical input eg: engineering, planning and land resumption powers and skills. The Commonwealth-State dispute over the Motorway has evolved because the State produced a deficient plan and demanded that it be funded. The Commonwealth proposed its own solution - had it confirmed by the respected engineering firm, Maunsells - and has been dragging the State toward its implementation.
The Prime Minister and successive Federal Roads and Transport Ministers have committed again and again on the public record to the full implementation of the Maunsells findings which include upgrading the Motorway east of the Logan interchange and building the Goodna Bypass. To that end, they have already provided a total of $550M.
The Goodna Bypass project involves extending the Logan Motorway from Gailes to join directly onto the Warrego and Cunningham Highways at Dinmore. Located at the western end of the Ipswich Motorway corridor, this new four-lane road would provide a total of eight lanes and two routes between Dinmore and Gailes. This is by far the most heavily trafficked section of the Ipswich Motorway. The Bypass would separate heavy and through transport from local commuters on the existing motorway. It would take heavy trucks out of Goodna and create an alternative if either road was blocked. Because the bypass involves a green-field site, disruption to traffic during construction would be minimised.
By comparison, the State wants to upgrade the corresponding section of the Ipswich Motorway to six lanes - a proposal which has none of the above virtues. The timetable for the construction of the State's proposed upgrade - as presented by the State Government - concluded in 2012. Since the 2004 election, the Commonwealth has proceeded as quickly as possible to complete the necessary planning for the bypass. It provided full funding to upgrade the Logan Interchange; the Centenary Interchange and to six-lane the connecting section of motorway - all to the State Government's existing plans.
Immediately after the election, in November 2004, the State Government promised to support the Federal Government in proceeding with the bypass. What follows is the relevant section from the press release:
"Paul Lucas said Queensland welcomed the appointment of respected engineering firm Maunsell Australia to independently evaluate the proposed Ipswich northern bypass.
"The Queensland Government will do all in its power to cooperate with the Federal Government in delivering their roads priorities, including the northern bypass," he said."The simple fact is that the Australian Government is providing the money for the national highway and they decide how their money is spent.
"The Queensland Government's position has always been that we must upgrade the Ipswich Motorway regardless of whether the northern bypass is feasible or not," Mr Lucas said.
He said Maunsell Australia would complete an interim feasibility report on the northern bypass by late February 2005 and a final report by the end of April 2005.
"If the feasibility study indicates the northern bypass is not a viable project, Queensland and the Commonwealth will need to look again at how we address traffic congestion on the Ipswich Motorway." Last year the Maunsell Report (quoted above by Mr Lucas) found there were three feasible routes for the Goodna Bypass (aka the northern bypass). It found that forecast traffic couldn't be carried in the existing Dinmore to Gailes corridor, no matter how much the road was upgraded. A six-lane motorway between Gailes and Dinmore could fail (ie: traffic congestion could reach current levels) just five years after completion � possibly sooner depending on traffic volumes.
The report found that in contrast any one of the three feasible alignments for the Goodna Bypass would deal effectively with traffic volumes for at least 25-30 years. It found the bypass could be complete in 2012-2013 - or 2010, if the State was prepared to grant the project "major project" status. It also suggested that in addition to the bypass, the Commonwealth should fund the six-laning of the road east of the Logan where traffic numbers were lower than Dinmore-Gailes, but increasing.
In the wake of the Maunsells feasibility report and its clear endorsement of the bypass, the State Government nevertheless opted out of its commitment of support. It tried again to float plans for its preferred upgrade. This it did in the face of Maunsells� findings that the upgrade was insufficient to meet the needs of the region.
It put to the Commonwealth a plan to complete the entire upgrade by the end of 2009. Maunsells was commissioned to review this new proposal. It reported that the new scheme put forward by the State did not allow even a single day for rain (page 1) � a factor that would add six months over a three year time frame given normal rainfall allowances. On page 8 it found there were unrealistic time allowances for bridge construction � one month to build new rail bridges � four months for a motorway overpass and five months for a Centenary Highway Interchange overpass.
It criticised proposals for �island� worksites between live traffic (page 8) and worksites that were too long and narrow that would slow productivity and delay completion.
After consideration by the Commonwealth this proposal by the state was rejected � partly because of the doubts expressed by Maunsells, but also because the work schedule put forward by the State would have required massive construction projects along the full 19km length of the Motorway at the same time.
Concurrent 24hr traffic delays due to construction would have affected the whole motorway for at least two of the three years � assuming no rain etc � but disruption during the third year would still be occurring along much of the road.
All this to deliver a road that would be defunct a short time after its completion.
Having considered the State�s proposal, the Prime Minister came to Queensland in November and recommitted his support for the Goodna Bypass. In line with the recommendations of the Maunsells Feasibility report, he provided $320M to six-lane the motorway east of the Logan up to and including a redesigned Centenary interchange. Work to spend this $320M and the $160M allocated to the Logan interchange in 2004 can start as soon as the State can award a tender.
He also commissioned Maunsells to decide which of the three bypass routes is preferred, how much it will cost, what is the preferred method of delivery eg: an alliance or a design and construct type contract and the business case for delivery.
I understand Maunsells� job is to prepare all that is required to take the Goodna Bypass project to a tender.
This current report will analyse flood afflux and undermining in relation to the three routes and consider other factors such as cost and community views. It may settle on any of the three (or possibly a combination of elements from the various options).
There will be three stages in this report.
1. At the end of this month, Maunsells will report on the afflux and undermining issues. Engineering solutions may have to be found and incorporated in the plan if either of these issues are found to be a factor. By the way, undermining is certainly a factor on the State's preferred upgrade project. The State's proposed alignment over the old rifle range at Redbank is undermined by the old Westphalen Colliery. As yet the full engineering solution to that problem has not been documented. Under the State plan, it is impossible to avoid that undermined alignment. The State is yet to discover what the final impact of that problem would be (in terms of cost and buildability).
2. In November Maunsells are to decide on the bypass route
3. In December they will finalise the business case.
In April 2004, the Commonwealth gave $160m to upgrade the Logan interchange - to redirect all the merges to the left hand side of the road, to re-align the motorway at that intersection and to widen the motorway to six lanes under the Logan overpass.
To implement the Maunsells recommendations, the Commonwealth�s additional $320m will upgrade the existing motorway to six lanes from the Centenary Highway to the Logan interchange (inclusive). With the existing work on the Granard Rd interchange and the Woogaroo Creek Bridge (both funded by the Commonwealth in 2001), this brings the current total Commonwealth allocation to the motorway to $550m.
The fact that the Commonwealth gave full funding to the Logan interchange two years ago (and still the State Govt has not announced the successful tender), or that Granard Rd was funded five years ago (and still is not complete) are sources for quite some frustration at the Commonwealth end.
But in addition, you might note a more recent press release about the $320M Wacol-Darra project which contained the following quotes from Mr Lucas:
Mr Lucas said drilling rigs were being set up and surveyors would be on site over the next few weeks carrying out preconstruction and survey work.
"Drilling and survey works to investigate ground conditions alongside the motorway would allow the bulldozers to roll on the Wacol � Darra section early in 2007.
"Early indications from Main Roads are that the upgrade of the Wacol to Darra section, including reconstruction of the Centenary Highway interchange will take around three years to complete," he said.
That start date ('bulldozers to roll") has now been delayed by six months because the State Government's plans for the Centenary Interchange had the proposed Springfield railway line - which crosses through the intersection - drawn in the wrong location.
In addition, the Commonwealth�s $320M allocation was also to provide an upgraded interchange at Progress Rd. Now the State has cancelled this part of the project � at least until it revisits its Westgate Development proposal � which was to open up all the land between the river and the Motorway from Woogaroo Creek to the Centenary Highway including disused hospital sites, the golf courses and other state-owned land. The State government cancelled its plans for this site immediately prior to the current election campaign.
This is the full story on the current state of play. I can provide further explanations if you would like them. The recent budget provides full funding for all the Ipswich Motorway work that the State has requested and says it is able to complete in the coming 12 months. Obviously and not surprisingly; the total is nowhere near $550M.
The State Transport Minister, Paul Lucas, is continuing to promote a short-sighted scheme that would be a bigger disaster than the last motorway upgrade, which was opened by Laurie Brereton and David Hamill in 1994 after six years of work. It didn't last seven years. The accepted capacity of a six lane road is 80,000 vehicles per day - vpd. Two years ago, our four-lane road was already carrying 100,000 vpd average on weekdays, 107,000 average on Fridays and 80,000 average on Sundays. (measured by the Qld MRD at Goodna) The idea that we should dig up this road and disrupt traffic for five years or more to produce a six lane replacement - and no alternative route has been discredited ever since it was reviewed by Maunsells. This is the full story on the saga so far. Please come back to me if you want other info.
Cameron.
Thank you for your email about the Ipswich Motorway. What follows is a blow-by blow response that covers all the history of the motorway since the first Auslink funding was allocated by the Commonwealth in 2004. Since then, I have included regular updates on Ipswich Motorway funding and progress in my electorate newsletter the Thompson Tribune.
Firstly, the funding/building relationship in relation to national highways (those that carry a preponderance of interstate freight): Basically, the Commonwealth is supposed to pay the money, while the State is supposed to provide all the practical input eg: engineering, planning and land resumption powers and skills. The Commonwealth-State dispute over the Motorway has evolved because the State produced a deficient plan and demanded that it be funded. The Commonwealth proposed its own solution - had it confirmed by the respected engineering firm, Maunsells - and has been dragging the State toward its implementation.
The Prime Minister and successive Federal Roads and Transport Ministers have committed again and again on the public record to the full implementation of the Maunsells findings which include upgrading the Motorway east of the Logan interchange and building the Goodna Bypass. To that end, they have already provided a total of $550M.
The Goodna Bypass project involves extending the Logan Motorway from Gailes to join directly onto the Warrego and Cunningham Highways at Dinmore. Located at the western end of the Ipswich Motorway corridor, this new four-lane road would provide a total of eight lanes and two routes between Dinmore and Gailes. This is by far the most heavily trafficked section of the Ipswich Motorway. The Bypass would separate heavy and through transport from local commuters on the existing motorway. It would take heavy trucks out of Goodna and create an alternative if either road was blocked. Because the bypass involves a green-field site, disruption to traffic during construction would be minimised.
By comparison, the State wants to upgrade the corresponding section of the Ipswich Motorway to six lanes - a proposal which has none of the above virtues. The timetable for the construction of the State's proposed upgrade - as presented by the State Government - concluded in 2012. Since the 2004 election, the Commonwealth has proceeded as quickly as possible to complete the necessary planning for the bypass. It provided full funding to upgrade the Logan Interchange; the Centenary Interchange and to six-lane the connecting section of motorway - all to the State Government's existing plans.
Immediately after the election, in November 2004, the State Government promised to support the Federal Government in proceeding with the bypass. What follows is the relevant section from the press release:
"Paul Lucas said Queensland welcomed the appointment of respected engineering firm Maunsell Australia to independently evaluate the proposed Ipswich northern bypass.
"The Queensland Government will do all in its power to cooperate with the Federal Government in delivering their roads priorities, including the northern bypass," he said."The simple fact is that the Australian Government is providing the money for the national highway and they decide how their money is spent.
"The Queensland Government's position has always been that we must upgrade the Ipswich Motorway regardless of whether the northern bypass is feasible or not," Mr Lucas said.
He said Maunsell Australia would complete an interim feasibility report on the northern bypass by late February 2005 and a final report by the end of April 2005.
"If the feasibility study indicates the northern bypass is not a viable project, Queensland and the Commonwealth will need to look again at how we address traffic congestion on the Ipswich Motorway." Last year the Maunsell Report (quoted above by Mr Lucas) found there were three feasible routes for the Goodna Bypass (aka the northern bypass). It found that forecast traffic couldn't be carried in the existing Dinmore to Gailes corridor, no matter how much the road was upgraded. A six-lane motorway between Gailes and Dinmore could fail (ie: traffic congestion could reach current levels) just five years after completion � possibly sooner depending on traffic volumes.
The report found that in contrast any one of the three feasible alignments for the Goodna Bypass would deal effectively with traffic volumes for at least 25-30 years. It found the bypass could be complete in 2012-2013 - or 2010, if the State was prepared to grant the project "major project" status. It also suggested that in addition to the bypass, the Commonwealth should fund the six-laning of the road east of the Logan where traffic numbers were lower than Dinmore-Gailes, but increasing.
In the wake of the Maunsells feasibility report and its clear endorsement of the bypass, the State Government nevertheless opted out of its commitment of support. It tried again to float plans for its preferred upgrade. This it did in the face of Maunsells� findings that the upgrade was insufficient to meet the needs of the region.
It put to the Commonwealth a plan to complete the entire upgrade by the end of 2009. Maunsells was commissioned to review this new proposal. It reported that the new scheme put forward by the State did not allow even a single day for rain (page 1) � a factor that would add six months over a three year time frame given normal rainfall allowances. On page 8 it found there were unrealistic time allowances for bridge construction � one month to build new rail bridges � four months for a motorway overpass and five months for a Centenary Highway Interchange overpass.
It criticised proposals for �island� worksites between live traffic (page 8) and worksites that were too long and narrow that would slow productivity and delay completion.
After consideration by the Commonwealth this proposal by the state was rejected � partly because of the doubts expressed by Maunsells, but also because the work schedule put forward by the State would have required massive construction projects along the full 19km length of the Motorway at the same time.
Concurrent 24hr traffic delays due to construction would have affected the whole motorway for at least two of the three years � assuming no rain etc � but disruption during the third year would still be occurring along much of the road.
All this to deliver a road that would be defunct a short time after its completion.
Having considered the State�s proposal, the Prime Minister came to Queensland in November and recommitted his support for the Goodna Bypass. In line with the recommendations of the Maunsells Feasibility report, he provided $320M to six-lane the motorway east of the Logan up to and including a redesigned Centenary interchange. Work to spend this $320M and the $160M allocated to the Logan interchange in 2004 can start as soon as the State can award a tender.
He also commissioned Maunsells to decide which of the three bypass routes is preferred, how much it will cost, what is the preferred method of delivery eg: an alliance or a design and construct type contract and the business case for delivery.
I understand Maunsells� job is to prepare all that is required to take the Goodna Bypass project to a tender.
This current report will analyse flood afflux and undermining in relation to the three routes and consider other factors such as cost and community views. It may settle on any of the three (or possibly a combination of elements from the various options).
There will be three stages in this report.
1. At the end of this month, Maunsells will report on the afflux and undermining issues. Engineering solutions may have to be found and incorporated in the plan if either of these issues are found to be a factor. By the way, undermining is certainly a factor on the State's preferred upgrade project. The State's proposed alignment over the old rifle range at Redbank is undermined by the old Westphalen Colliery. As yet the full engineering solution to that problem has not been documented. Under the State plan, it is impossible to avoid that undermined alignment. The State is yet to discover what the final impact of that problem would be (in terms of cost and buildability).
2. In November Maunsells are to decide on the bypass route
3. In December they will finalise the business case.
In April 2004, the Commonwealth gave $160m to upgrade the Logan interchange - to redirect all the merges to the left hand side of the road, to re-align the motorway at that intersection and to widen the motorway to six lanes under the Logan overpass.
To implement the Maunsells recommendations, the Commonwealth�s additional $320m will upgrade the existing motorway to six lanes from the Centenary Highway to the Logan interchange (inclusive). With the existing work on the Granard Rd interchange and the Woogaroo Creek Bridge (both funded by the Commonwealth in 2001), this brings the current total Commonwealth allocation to the motorway to $550m.
The fact that the Commonwealth gave full funding to the Logan interchange two years ago (and still the State Govt has not announced the successful tender), or that Granard Rd was funded five years ago (and still is not complete) are sources for quite some frustration at the Commonwealth end.
But in addition, you might note a more recent press release about the $320M Wacol-Darra project which contained the following quotes from Mr Lucas:
Mr Lucas said drilling rigs were being set up and surveyors would be on site over the next few weeks carrying out preconstruction and survey work.
"Drilling and survey works to investigate ground conditions alongside the motorway would allow the bulldozers to roll on the Wacol � Darra section early in 2007.
"Early indications from Main Roads are that the upgrade of the Wacol to Darra section, including reconstruction of the Centenary Highway interchange will take around three years to complete," he said.
That start date ('bulldozers to roll") has now been delayed by six months because the State Government's plans for the Centenary Interchange had the proposed Springfield railway line - which crosses through the intersection - drawn in the wrong location.
In addition, the Commonwealth�s $320M allocation was also to provide an upgraded interchange at Progress Rd. Now the State has cancelled this part of the project � at least until it revisits its Westgate Development proposal � which was to open up all the land between the river and the Motorway from Woogaroo Creek to the Centenary Highway including disused hospital sites, the golf courses and other state-owned land. The State government cancelled its plans for this site immediately prior to the current election campaign.
This is the full story on the current state of play. I can provide further explanations if you would like them. The recent budget provides full funding for all the Ipswich Motorway work that the State has requested and says it is able to complete in the coming 12 months. Obviously and not surprisingly; the total is nowhere near $550M.
The State Transport Minister, Paul Lucas, is continuing to promote a short-sighted scheme that would be a bigger disaster than the last motorway upgrade, which was opened by Laurie Brereton and David Hamill in 1994 after six years of work. It didn't last seven years. The accepted capacity of a six lane road is 80,000 vehicles per day - vpd. Two years ago, our four-lane road was already carrying 100,000 vpd average on weekdays, 107,000 average on Fridays and 80,000 average on Sundays. (measured by the Qld MRD at Goodna) The idea that we should dig up this road and disrupt traffic for five years or more to produce a six lane replacement - and no alternative route has been discredited ever since it was reviewed by Maunsells. This is the full story on the saga so far. Please come back to me if you want other info.
Cameron.